Skip to main content

Table 4 Durable solutions scales by indicator

From: Measuring impact: a cross-sectional multi-stage cluster survey to assess the attainment of durable solutions in post-tsunami Aceh, Indonesia

Ā 

Standard of living

Safety and security

Access to livelihoods

Participation in public affairs

Restitution of property

Pre-Tsunami Conditions

Household Size

0.312 (ā€“0.142 ā€“ 0.766)

0.245 (-0.492 ā€“ 0.982)

-0.680*** (-1.019 ā€“ 0.341)

-0.092 (-0.67ā€“ 0.486)

-0.138 (-0.687 ā€“ 0.411)

Education of Head of Household

ā€ƒLess than Primary

REF

REF

REF

REF

REF

ā€ƒPrimary

0.823 (-2.255 ā€“ 3.902)

-0.546 (-3.159 ā€“ 2.067)

0.585 (-3.726 ā€“ 4.896)

1.613 (-3.175 ā€“ 6.401)

0.462 (-2.465 ā€“ 3.388)

ā€ƒSecondary

1.108 (-1.777 ā€“ 3.992)

-1.194 (-4.757 ā€“ 2.370)

2.092 (-2.356 ā€“ 6.540)

2.432 (-1.969 ā€“ 6.833)

1.586 (-0.825 ā€“ 3.997)

ā€ƒHigh School

1.621 (-1.494 ā€“ 4.735)

-1.348 (-3.358 ā€“ 0.661)

3.839* (-0.510 ā€“ 8.189)

2.186 (-2.377 ā€“ 6.750)

0.241 (-2.744 ā€“ 3.226)

ā€ƒCollege or University

5.807*** (2.619 ā€“ 8.995)

-0.685 (-3.320 ā€“ 1.950)

8.818*** (4.632 ā€“ 13.00)

2.938 (-1.813 ā€“ 7.690)

2.077 (-1.025 ā€“ 5.179)

Number of Household Members Employed

0.423 (-1.018 ā€“ 1.865)

0.185 (-0.795 ā€“ 1.166)

1.742*** (0.561 ā€“ 2.923)

1.088 (-0.291 ā€“ 2.467)

-1.348 (-3.069 ā€“ 0.373)

Employment Status of Head of Household

2.11 (-3.432 ā€“ 7.653)

-12.15*** (-19.59 ā€“ ā€“4.719)

4.552* (-0.229 ā€“ 9.333)

-8.403*** (-13.970 ā€“ 2.837)

2.337 (-2.872 ā€“ 7.545)

Home Owned

-1.182 (-5.140 ā€“ 2.776)

-2.318 (-5.809 ā€“ 1.173)

1.054 (-1.465 ā€“ 3.573)

2.117 (-2.330 ā€“ 6.564)

12.19** (0.798 ā€“ 23.58)

Monthly Income ($10 USD)

0.157*** (0.0520 ā€“ 0.262)

0.091* (-0.0057 ā€“ 0.188)

0.349*** (0.264 ā€“ 0.434)

-0.060 (-0.152 ā€“ 0.032)

0.047 (-0.021 ā€“ 0.115)

Tsunami Damages

Distance of Home from Coast

-0.00092 (-0.0116 ā€“ 0.0098)

-0.00025 (-0.0102 ā€“ 0.097)

-0.0027 (-0.0149 ā€“ 0.0096)

-0.0127* (-0.028 ā€“ 0.002)

0.0016 (-0.005 ā€“ 0.008)

Number of Tsunami-Related Deaths in Household

-0.376 (-1.005 ā€“ 0.253)

-0.459 (-1.129 ā€“ 0.211)

-0.784*** (-1.316 ā€“ 0.251)

-0.310 (-1.153 ā€“ 0.534)

-0.0225 (-0.745 ā€“ 0.700)

Tsunamiā€“Related Damage

ā€ƒNo Damage

REF

REF

REF

REF

REF

ā€ƒMinor Damage

-1.493 (-3.619 ā€“ 0.634)

-1.853 (-5.200 ā€“ 1.493)

-1.852 (-5.671 ā€“ 1.967)

1.422 (-2.610 ā€“ 5.454)

-1.008 (-4.496 ā€“ 2.481)

ā€ƒMajor Damage

-3.442* (-7.057 ā€“ 0.173)

-1.687 (-5.007 ā€“ 1.634)

-1.318 (-5.630 ā€“ 2.993)

2.609 (-2.450 ā€“ 7.668)

-1.112 (-4.349 ā€“ 2.125)

ā€ƒDestroyed Completely

-4.902*** (-8.436 ā€“ 1.369)

4.248** (0.602 ā€“ 7.894)

-1.594 (-6.512 ā€“ 3.323)

0.736 (-3.806 ā€“ 5.277)

-3.218* (-6.840 ā€“ 0.404)

Displacement

Living in Same Village

-3.233* (-6.892 ā€“ 0.426)

3.708* (-0.709 ā€“ 8.126)

-2.090* (-4.496 ā€“ 0.315)

-0.926 (-6.751 ā€“ 4.900)

8.602* (-0.314 ā€“ 17.52)

Total Displacement Duration (months)

-0.139*** (-0.207 ā€“ 0.0719)

-0.197*** (-0.328 ā€“ 0.067)

-0.0388 (-0.116 ā€“ 0.0386)

0.048 (-0.057 ā€“ 0.153)

0.029 (-0.0798 ā€“ 0.138)

Ever Displaced to a Barrack

0.833 (-1.316 ā€“ 2.982)

0.403 (-1.092 ā€“ 1.899)

-0.0817 (-1.353 ā€“ 1.189)

-1.073 (-3.433 ā€“ 1.286)

1.152 (-0.679 ā€“ 2.984)

Ever Stayed with a Host Family

1.374 (-0.364 ā€“ 3.113)

-0.458 (-2.303 ā€“ 1.386)

-0.16 (-1.776 ā€“ 1.455)

-0.185 (-2.281 ā€“ 1.912)

0.303 (-1.879 ā€“ 2.485)

Assistance Received

Received Shelter Assistance

4.218*** (2.053 ā€“ 6.384)

-1.659 (-4.112 ā€“ 0.794)

-0.356 (-2.466 ā€“ 1.753)

-2.884* (-6.218 ā€“ 0.450)

1.326 (-2.124 ā€“ 4.776)

Received Livelihood Assistance

0.4 (-1.169 ā€“ 1.970)

-1.063 (-3.042 ā€“ 0.917)

-1.705** (-3.324 ā€“ ā€“0.0860)

2.156** (0.212 ā€“ 4.100)

-1.723* (-3.775 ā€“ 0.329)

Received Food Assistance

1.675 (-4.523 ā€“ 7.872)

1.398 (-6.336 ā€“ 9.132)

-0.974 (-8.848 ā€“ 6.900)

42.58*** (33.99 ā€“ 51.17)

-1.735 (-9.017 ā€“ 5.548)

Received Drinking Water Assistance

-0.207 (-4.613 ā€“ 4.198)

-5.13 (-12.33 ā€“ 2.068)

3.409 (-0.824 ā€“ 7.643)

1.241 (-5.037 ā€“ 7.518)

2.525 (-1.627 ā€“ 6.677)

Received Water for Hygiene

3.293** (0.0227 ā€“ 6.562)

3.654 (-5.737 ā€“ 13.04)

-3.957 (-8.985 ā€“ 1.071)

2.150 (-4.454 ā€“ 8.754)

-3.489** (-6.408 ā€“ ā€“0.570)

Received Healthcare Assistance

-2.41 (-8.146 ā€“ 3.326)

-1.475 (-6.498 ā€“ 3.549)

3.946 (-2.307 ā€“ 10.20)

-0.589 (-6.132 ā€“ 4.954)

-1.142 (-6.306 ā€“ 4.022)

Received Legal Assistance

2.153** (0.306 ā€“ 3.999)

1.422 (-0.729 ā€“ 3.573)

1.434** (0.138 ā€“ 2.730)

-1.882* (-4.114 ā€“ 0.349)

1.055 (-0.759 ā€“ 2.869)

Received Sanitation Assistance

0.225 (-4.240 ā€“ 4.690)

-2.316 (-5.822 ā€“ 1.190)

1.073 (-2.036 ā€“ 4.182)

-1.969 (-6.387 ā€“ 2.449)

-0.483 (-3.678 ā€“ 2.712)

  1. ***pā€‰<ā€‰0.01, **pā€‰<ā€‰0.05, *pā€‰<ā€‰0.1, Data presented are adjusted beta coefficients and (95% Confidence Intervals).
  2. All models additionally adjusted for pre-tsunami living conditions (type of roof, source of water) and satisfaction with community infrastructure (school, health clinic, water and electric services, mosque facility, and roads).