Table 10 Quantitative financial outcomes (studies included in review where data provided)
Authors (date) | Number of clients seen | Total lump sum/one off payments gained | Mean lump sum/one off payments per client seen | Recurring benefits gained (per year) | Mean recurring benefits (per year) per client seen |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Bennett (1997)[82] | 49 | £28 121.00 | £573.898 | £41 860.00 | £854.29 |
Bundy (2002)[87] | 561 | £183 147.00 | £326.47 | £762 042.00 | £1358.36 |
Bundy (2003)[88] | 818 | £261 231.00 | £319.35 | £474 587.00 | £580.18 |
Coppell et al (1999)[43] | 270 | £15 863.00 | £58.75 | £28 028.00 | £103.81 |
Cornwallis & O;Neill (1997)[65] | 102 | £66 785.00 | £654.75 | not reported | not reported |
Derbyshire CC WRS (1997)[89] | 428 | £73 643.07 | £172.06 | £527 352.90 | £1232.13 |
Derbyshire CC WRS (1998a)[22] | 480 | £117 405.20 | £244.59 | £573 995.20 | £1195.82 |
Derbyshire CC WRS (1998b)[22] | 290 | £56 967.87 | £196.44 | £374 630.40 | £1291.83 |
Frost-Gaskin et al (2003)[66] | 153 | £60 323.34 | £394.27 | £281 805.80 | £1841.87 |
Greasley (2003)[95] & Greasley and Small (2005)[96] | 2484 | £431 198.00 | £173.59 | £1 940 543.00 | £781.22 |
Griffiths (1992)[97] | 157 | £32 708.00 | £208.33 | £87 131.20 | £554.98 |
Hastie (2003)[98] | 492 | £39 688.00 | £80.67 | £173 108.00 | £351.85 |
High Peak CAB (1995)[99] | 39 | not reported | not reported | £38 646.40 | £990.93 |
High Peak CAB (2001)[100] | 236 | £9 069.74 | £38.43 | £24 934.52 | £105.65 |
High Peak CAB (2003)[101] | 156 | £4765.63 | £30.55 | £60 201.96 | £385.91 |
Hoskins et al (in press)[102] | 630 | £119 515.44 | £189.71 | £1 016 908.70 | £1 614.14 |
Memel & Gubbay (1999)[57] | 46 | not reported | not reported | £73 872.00 | £1605.91 |
Memel et al (2002)[24] | 19 | not reported | not reported | £38 725.00 | £2038.16 |
Middlesbrough WR (1999)[107] | 272 | not reported | not reported | £473 053.00 | £1739.17 |
Middleton et al (1993a)[69] | 52 | £10 393.00 | £199.87 | £14 359.00 | £276.13 |
Middleton et al (1993b)[69] | 583 | £12 559.80 | £21.54 | £8 373.20 | £14.36 |
Moffatt (2004)[109] | 25 | £5 766.00 | £230.64 | £37 442.08 | £1497.68 |
Paris & Player (1993)[71] | 150 | £3 371.00 | £22.47 | £54 929.58 | £366.20 |
Reading et al (2002)[72] | 23 | £4 389.00 | £190.83 | £6 480.00 | £281.74 |
Southwark CC MAC (1998)[114] | 621 | £160 593.00 | £258.60 | £390 500.00 | £628.82 |
Vaccarello (2004)[115] | 206 | £11 433.00 | £55.50 | £137 819.00 | £669.02 |
Veitch (1995)[21] – mental health | 35 | £16 122.90 | £460.65 | £25 581.40 | £730.90 |
Veitch (1995)[21] – GP | 37 | £28 783.69 | £777.94 | £74 025.64 | £2000.69 |
Widdowfield & Rickard (1996)[116] | 106 | not reported | not reported | £183 790.20 | £1733.87 |
Totals |  | £1 753 843 and 9038 clients, mean = £194 per client | £7 864 910 and 9418 clients, mean = £832 per year per client | ||